Skip to content

Pluto’s Secret for Nonfiction Monday

At one of my other blogs I have been participating in a book review round up for children's nonfiction for a number of years called Nonfiction Monday. The organizer, Anastasia Suen, has recently changed the format so now all the reviews are posted Mondays on the new Nonfiction Monday blog. Today I thought I would participate here at Growing with Science with a review of a picture book about Pluto. If you are interested in children's nonfiction, you might want to go visit the blog and see what interesting books other bloggers have found.

nonfictionmonday

With the the change in 2006 from having nine planets in the solar system to only eight, children may be wondering what happened to Pluto. Why isn't it a planet any longer?  Pluto's Secret: An Icy World's Tale of Discovery by Margaret Weitekamp, with David DeVorkin, and illustrated by Diane Kidd uses a whimsical approach to explain the discovery of Pluto, its history and how scientific classifications change as we uncover more information about the world around us.

plutos-secret

The premise is that Pluto has a secret, which is that it isn’t a planet but part of a different phenomenon altogether. The cartoon illustrations of a smiling Pluto reveal right away that this isn't going to be a deeply serious nonfiction book. The lighthearted tone of the text confirms that this is meant to be a fun, entertaining look at what happened. That doesn't mean that the information is lightweight, however, because the book is published in association with Smithsonian's National Air and Space Museum where the authors and illustrator work. It is well written and has a good amount of depth.

What did happen to Pluto? In a nutshell, astronomers found a group of objects that also orbit around the sun near Pluto. Together they form what is called the Kuiper belt. Many of these newly discovered objects are nearly as large as Pluto, and one, Eris, was actually thought to be larger than Pluto. Eris would have been the 10th planet in the solar system, except in 2006 astronomers sat down and decided to set a strict definition of what a planet should be. As a group they decided that a planet has to orbit the sun, have a rounded shape, and also to have a clear orbit of its own. Pluto and the other members of the Kuiper belt fail the last criterion. Therefore, they are now called "dwarf planets." Because they are for the most part orbiting beyond Neptune, they are also called "trans-Neptunian objects." The only dwarf planet the orbits nearer to the Sun than Neptune is Ceres, which is found in the asteroid belt between Earth and Mars.

KBO_Size_br

This illustration (from NASA) shows some of the best known objects in the Kuiper Belt in comparison to Earth. It was labeled before the objects got their official names, which are:

Top row (left to right): Eris and its moon, Dysnomia (not "Xena"); Pluto and Charon; and Makemake.

Bottom row (left to right): Haumea and its moons; and Kuiper Belt Objects Sedna and Quaoar.

Back to the book, Pluto's Secret is a lively introduction to the the history of Pluto and how science works. It definitely would be a useful resource for a unit on the solar system or to accompany a trip to an air and space museum.

Age Range: 5 - 9 years
Hardcover: 40 pages
Publisher: Harry N. Abrams (March 12, 2013)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 1419704230
ISBN-13: 978-1419704239

Disclosure: I am an affiliate with Amazon so I can provide you with cover images and links to more information about books and products. As you probably are aware, if you click through the highlighted title link and purchase a product, I will receive a very small commission, at not extra cost to you. Any proceeds help defray the costs of hosting and maintaining this website.

 

5 thoughts on “Pluto’s Secret for Nonfiction Monday

  1. Pingback: Pluto’s Secret: An Icy World’s Tale of Discovery | Nonfiction Monday

  2. Roberta

    Yes, sassy is the word for it. While researching the book I found out that Mickey Mouse's dog Pluto was named for the planet. That's how popular it was when it was first discovered.

  3. Laurel Kornfeld

    Our solar system does not have only eight planets. This "secret" that Pluto isn't a planet represents only one side in an ongoing debate. I urge you to give your students the opportunity to read both sides of the story. Look for the books "Ten Worlds" by Dr. Ken Croswell, "Thirteen Planets" by Dr. David Aguilar (a National Geographic book), and "The Case for Pluto" by Alan Boyle. Only four percent of the IAU voted on the controversial demotion and most are not planetary scientists. Their decision was opposed by hundreds of professional astronomers in a formal petition led by New Horizons Principal Investigator Dr. Alan Stern. You can find that petition here:
    http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/planetprotest . The status of Pluto remains very much an ongoing debate.

  4. Roberta

    Laurel,

    Thanks for bringing this up. Isn't it interesting that there had not been a formal definition of a planet before 2006?

    I personally was more interested in the part of the story where scientists can change classification schemes as they find out more information, rather than whether or not Pluto is a planet. In biology, classification is particularly fluid right now because we are using DNA analysis to find out sometimes what appears to be closely related species are not as close as we thought and, conversely, some species that appear to be very different on the surface are in fact related. It does mean there are a lot of ongoing name changes, some of which are also controversial. Science is not a bag of facts to be memorized, no matter how much we would like it to be.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *